9th Cir. Affirms To Drop Plavix Makers’ Injunction Case

  • Testosterone Replacement Therapy Medical Record Review & Outsourcing Services

Last week, a 9th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals panel affirmed the decision of the district court to dismiss a lawsuit filed by pharmaceutical companies seeking an injunction to drop Hawaii state court litigation against Plavix, a medication used help prevent heart attacks and strokes.

The State of Hawaii filed a lawsuit in 2014 against the manufacturers alleging deceptive marketing practices. The state claimed that the companies knew about the worse clinical outcomes associated with Plavix when taken by a certain genetic variation, a group that includes a significant portion of Hawaii’s population.

Earlier this year, in January, the companies filed a federal court lawsuit asking for an injunction against the state court proceeding, disputing that the case violated their constitutional right to free speech.

The district court dismissed the suit, invoking the Younger abstention doctrine that generally bars federal courts from restraining state criminal prosecutions.

The 9th Circuit affirmed the lower court’s decision stating that the Hawaii action fell within the class of cases because the action was brought “under a statute that punishes those who engage in deceptive acts in commerce, and the state sought civil penalties and punitive damages to sanction the companies for their allegedly deceptive labeling practices.

The panel also noted that the case did not fall within Younger’s extraordinary circumstances exception, rejecting the companies’ concerns raised during the arguments.

We are social:



NSIC-CRISIL has assigned a "SE 2A" rating to Neural IT, indicating a company with High Performanc...

ISO 27001 Certification

Neural IT is officially ISO 27001:2013 (ISO 27001) certified by Alcumus ISOQAR Limited as the Cer...


Neural IT has successfully implemented HIPAA for securing Health records....



NYSTLA - "Neural IT is proud to be associated with NYSTLA (New York State Trial Lawyers Associati...


CAOC - "Neural IT is proud to be associated with CAOC (Consumer Attorneys of California) as a Ven...


CAALA - "Neural IT is proud to be associated with CAALA (Consumer Attorneys Association of Los An...

News & Events

Friends Of CAALA 2020
It is a treasured moment for Neural IT to be associated as an Affiliate Member for so many years and receive an…
Amidst the chaos of COVID-19 pandemic, we have something to cheer about as today is National Smile Day, and a smile is…
Happy Mother's Day from Neural IT
The cagey pandemic has halted our lives, but the only spirits that kept igniting during the crisis are the ones whom we…

Latest Tweets